Blog Widget by LinkWithin
白雪不是公主 snowXwhite on Facebook

Fighting world hunger

白雪不是公主 诱惑の香り Snow White is Not a Princess


Image Hosted by ImageShack.us

中午,我去食堂买饭。一包饭+两粒苹果是RM 4.60。我掏出了RM50,还有口袋里的RM0.50。收银员接过了RM50,把RM0.50放进了抽屉里,掏出了RM46对着我笑了。突然,我想起了Yasmin Ahmad的《Chocolate》。

I bought my lunch at canteen this afternoon. A packet of rice and two apples cost me RM 4.60. I took out RM 50 and the 50 cents in my pocket. The cashier received my money and put the coins in the drawer, returning RM 46 to me and smiled to me. Suddenly I remembered Yasmin Ahmad’s Chocolate.




你要我去的原因是不是你要跟你的男朋友在一起?
You only want me to go so that you can be with your boyfriend, right?
为什么不可以meh?
Even if true, what’s wrong with that?
他在骗着你的钱都不懂!
He is just taking advantage of you!
为什么?不可以啊?我高兴嘛~
What’s the problem as long as I am happy?

华人父母常有的个性,孩子做什么都看不过眼,自己做的,只要高兴就好。
One personality all Chinese parents have in common: whatever their child is doing, it has to be wrong in their eyes; whatever they are doing, it matters not whether it is right or wrong – as long as they are happy with it.  

 

其实Yasmin想告诉大家的是,年轻一辈生长在马来西亚的孩子内心都渴望与各族和谐相处,完全属于1Malaysia,实现不分你我,但由于外界的因素 (这里主要是说父母,当然还包括身边的朋友、长辈、国家政策、媒体和政治人物等等) 加上父母给我们的stereotype,有着这里是给他们那种人而已的马来亚式老套观念,再加上孩子本身以往的亲身经验(可能是没能在教育体制上得到更公平的对待),而这些一点一点的经验最终就形成了现在孩子们的prejudice。

What Yasmin is trying to tell us is that, the young generation that grow up in Malaysia wish to live in harmony with other races. They want to truly practice the concept 1Malaysia where race is irrelevant, but due to external factors (frankly speaking, this short film referring to parents mainly, but of course it covers other factors such as peer pressure, seniors, national policies, media, politicians and others), topped with parents’ stereotyping on us which contains the this-land-is-for-that-race-only paradigm, coupled with the young generation’s own experience (perhaps they did not acquire fair and just treatment in aspects like education), which slowly forms the prejudice in their minds. 


“你跟那个马来婆谈这么久做莫?”
“Why do you talk for so long with that Malay granny?”


在这话说出之前,男主角的眼神是柔和的、细腻的,当他妈妈喊他、并说出“马来婆”这带着贬义的称呼时,孩子突然态度转变暴躁地说“tak cukup tak payah beli lah”。
Before this question is asked, the main male character’s eyes were gentle but when his mother shouted a question at him, a question containing the term “Malay granny”, the boy suddenly became hot-tempered. He then said impatiently: “tak cukup tak payah beli lah.”


我们,是不是总是把“马来婆”挂在嘴边?
在你潜意识里,“马来婆”是不是总是带着贬低的意思?
Don’t we always use the term “Malay granny”?
Subconsciously, do you see this term as something that lowers the status of other race?


最后,孩子把巧克力放回柜台上,这个举动像是那种被打扰后心有闷气的肢体语言。马来女生会回来吗?我们不懂,男孩不懂,甚至连Yasmin Ahmad也不懂。但是我们知道,如果这种散播偏见的人一直存在着,唯恐天下不乱口出狂言,那么1Malaysia的精神就一直不会来敲门。

In the end, the boy put the chocolate back to the counter. It seems like an action of body language that shows frustration after being disturbed. Will the Malay girl come back? We don’t know. The boy didn’t know. Even Yasmin Ahmad didn’t know. But one thing for sure: if this prejudice remains, we will not be living in harmony, nor will the spirit of 1Malaysia come knocking at our doors.




Image Hosted by ImageShack.us
↑ 课外活动操步完,我们坐在树底下休息。
After marching for co-curricular activities, we rest under the trees.
 

其实所有的大学生都希望都跟各族好好地相处,但是由于媒体、父母、身边的朋友一直不断不断地重复告诉我们这块土地的教育体制有多不公平,所以让他们潜意识里对对方产生了不满。我在大学里要学会的,就是减少怨言。每当我遇到不公平的时候都不要抱怨,相反更应该积极奋斗地争取我认为最合适的公平。
Actually all undergraduates wish to communicate well with other races but because of media, parents and friends repetitively tell us about how unfair is the education system on this piece of land we are living on, we subconsciously feel dissatisfied with the way things are managed, and we subconsciously refuse to befriend people from other races. What I learned in varsity is to cease complaining. Whenever I encounter something unfair, I try my best not to complain. I know what I should be doing is to fight for the rights I believe I am entitled to.
 
 

Ps:我觉得Hon Kah Hoe小弟弟很养眼哟,尤其是他文质彬看着马来女生的时候,第一眼看见他站起来的时候就觉得他超像我家的弟弟,尤其是那身材,哈哈!我中学那段期间有两年的时间进出马大医院的心理医疗室,男主角Hon Kah Hoe在跟妈妈对谈的时候,手里重复玩弄着那些厨房用具,那是一种心理问题的表现。
I think Hon Kah Hoe is so adorable, especially when he gentle look at Malay girls. My first impression on him was that he closely resembles my brother, especially his body… haha! During my secondary school years, I spent two years paying frequent visit to HUKM’s psychotherapy consultation room. When Hon Kah Hoe was conversing with his mother, he kept fiddling kitchen utensils – I recognize that as an action done because of the existence of a psychological problem.  
 
 
 



Life is like a box of chocolate, we’ll never know what we’ll get.
笔于 19.08.2009 12:40am






相关短片:

【15Malaysia】'Chocolate' by Yasmin Ahmad


이올린에 북마크하기

Trackback Address :: http://www.snowxwhite.com/tc/trackback/1286

  1. well 2009/08/21 12:32 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    我对影片的看法和你很相似。在15Malaysia里留了类似的留言。

  2. mei ren yao 2009/08/21 12:46 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    this remind me about sepet

  3. 미키 2009/08/21 13:08 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    写得很好..~
    I will link you to my site..

  4. 挥洒自如 2009/08/21 14:01 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    我也很喜欢这短片。影片虽短但要传达的讯息好多!

  5. ahk3n 2009/08/21 14:26 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    至今我讀到這麼多對這齣短片的詮釋, 最貼切的莫過於星洲日報副總編輯鄭丁賢的那篇.

    在這裡和你, 也和大眾分享一下. :)

    http://opinions.sinchew-i.com/published/date/20090819/17

  6. ahk3n 2009/08/21 14:26 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    至今我讀到這麼多對這齣短片的詮釋, 最貼切的莫過於星洲日報副總編輯鄭丁賢的那篇.

    在這裡和你, 也和大眾分享一下. :)

    http://opinions.sinchew-i.com/published/date/20090819/17

  7. ahk3n 2009/08/21 14:26 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    至今我讀到這麼多對這齣短片的詮釋, 最貼切的莫過於星洲日報副總編輯鄭丁賢的那篇.

    在這裡和你, 也和大眾分享一下. :)

    http://opinions.sinchew-i.com/published/date/20090819/17

  8. 小澤 2009/08/21 15:23 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    開始些雙語了哦。。。
    加油~

    看了這個短片~
    也看看我的看后感吧~
    http://dsvt.blogspot.com/2009/08/15.html

  9. ahbing 2009/08/21 15:39 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    好久没回去马来西亚了,不知道1Malaysia的愿望迈进了多少0.00001%呢。。。

  10. TH@i 2009/08/21 17:08 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    其实我们有没有想过?现在才不分种族说“1 Malaysia”。那之前是不是“很多Malaysia”?最近的刚宣布的ASBN基金宣城是为了响应“1 Malaysia”的concept,但为何还分固打制来分配呢?“1 Malaysia”的意义又何从何在呢?

  11. kev 2009/08/21 20:34 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    一)从妈妈言语间说出了,这里是他们的,我们没有机会的。说出了华裔在这里的不公对待与无奈。

    二)说出了外国所给予的机会(奖学金),很大可能是影射着新加坡,但本地的却什么都没有给予。大家也会懂这是每一年都会吵一轮的课题吧。

    三)妈妈要孩子出外不再继续留在那里,说出了不少家长都希望孩子出国然后逃离马来西亚,赚多点钱的心态。(虽然有可能也是因为妈妈自己本身的自私)

    四)马来女孩的出现,和她主动地回笑示好,说出了不是所有马来人都如华人想象般地“恶劣”。很多其实是很单纯地很美丽的。

    五)华人男孩一开始对着那女生的态度,不是很友善,但一看到对方的正脸&主动示好后,他的表情变了,也糊涂拿错货品。说出了他对那女的其实很有意思的。这说出了不同种族间还是可以有爱。

    六)但忽然间,因为妈妈的一句话,让他“清醒”后,再次恢复旧有的敌对态度。也说出了华人对马来人的避忌,和脑海深处从小到长大,每一时每一刻被种植,对马来人持有的负观念。

    七)最后那男的是拿起那巧克力,应该是想拿去请给那个女生的。但被妈妈一喝快点进来,又把手上的巧克力给放下然后走回进去了。说明了现实上的华人也想踏出那第一步去主动示好,但还是被社会的旧有的设定和仇恨所蒙蔽,而把那冒起的善意给埋没了。

    八)影片暗地里说出了华人在大马所拥有的恶根性&排他性,因为少数的种族败类的影响,而全盘地反对对方的种族,就算对方其实是好人一个。

    九)五分钱也要计较,也是华人的陋习。

    十)对于普遍大马华人的恶言恶语,其实也有马来人是会默默承受。就如影片中的女孩,对着那男孩不礼貌语气的对待,并没有给予什么相等的情绪反应,而选择默默离开。所以其实马来人也是受害者。

    十一)新一代的华人&马来人试图走出旧有敌对的态度,但无奈地还是被以前所灌输的负思想所影响,大家还是无法抛开一切,当没有隔膜的朋友。

    终结,
    其实整部影片,
    该分成两部分。
    前半部分述说大马华人在大马不公的对待。
    后半部分述说着大马华人&马来人所存在的矛盾关系。
    两个部分在一起,
    可以让我们简单地看到,
    华人&马来人之间矛盾隔膜的起因,
    还有那影响(种族间的敌对&不合)。
    如果马来人让出了那第一步,
    华人是否会跟着走出那第二步呢?

  12. ping 2009/08/21 20:56 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    I wrote a post on this using dual-lingual (for the first time!)^^ I have a disclaimer says it is inspired by you Snowxwhite^^

    btw Kev has some nice points :)

  13. mossie 2009/08/21 22:13 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    tat is a nice video.
    malaysia is a very 矛盾 country.
    這種觀念已經深深埋在我們華人心理, 久久不能釋懷.

  14. jackal 2009/08/21 22:23 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    一天一苹果,医生远离我

  15. 药师 2009/08/22 20:53 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    我对这短片的看法,写在这里: http://nucifera.wordpress.com/2009/08/22/yasmin-ahmad%E7%9A%84chocolate/

  16. 小步舞曲 2009/08/22 22:20 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    kahoe is really really killing me!he is sooooo handsome &hot for me! i already couldnt resist when i first saw him in talentime!

    While i was watching this short film, i kept waiting for something more 'visual' to come next. However in the end of this REALLY SHORT film, i was dumbstrucked at the moment, was like"wat?! finish liao?!" In fact, it is not just about visual image only but it requires your thoughts and thinking. So i watched it again and again, until i truly get all the meaning tht yasmin was trying to send to us. uh, brilliant job i would say. indeed it is the reason why i love&respect kak so much.

    will be missing her more than alot.
    and i hope tht there's another great local director who has the ability to capture the truth of this country, in the future.

  17. 應。界 2009/08/23 02:03 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    我看著影片時,很不明白意思在哪,連看兩次也不明白。原來是這樣。謝謝你!

  18. ~:*:白雪不是公主:*:~ 2009/08/23 11:48 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    很多人看不明白,是因为看的人把注意力放在小小的东西上。为什么五分钱都不肯给,难道华人吝啬?马来人穷?有时候太过专注小小片的拼图,反而看不见了整副画 :-)

    我现在身后坐着几个华人男生,他们在说不明白chocolate什么意思。他们小小声地说,我在光明正大地听。哈。有一个男生说,我以为15部短片都是搞笑的,结果现在这部sien到死。我听着听着,心里有点疼。

  19. 2009/09/12 21:32 PERMALINK | EDIT/DEL | REPLY

    “我以为15部短片都是搞笑的,结果现在这部sien到死。我听着听着,心里有点疼。”

    针对这一点,可见,不是每个人都对身边的事物敏感,有想法。还有很多人,尤其是年轻人,都对这些社会现象不闻不问,抖抖肩膀就说不管我的事,这些人,真的拿他们没办法。如果每个人都对自己的公民意识有多一点认知,多一点关心,相信社会会不一样。



I'm your ~:*:白雪不是公主:*:~’s Blog is powered by textcube.org :: textcube skin by Nessarose.com